Everyday Wellbeing: Judging what really helps

Everyday Wellbeing, from Advanced Hypnotherapy

Therapy dogs are among the most loved ideas in wellbeing, so a null result lands hard. A new preprint, Dog-Assisted Therapy as a Complementary Intervention in the Therapeutic Process of Adolescents in a Mental Health Day Hospital, tested the idea in a randomised trial and found no clear difference on its main measures. It is a useful case for a bigger question: how do we tell what actually helps?

What the trial found

The trial involved 70 teenagers aged 12 to 18 in a mental health day hospital. Some had eight extra sessions with a dog alongside their usual care; the others had usual care alone. On overall clinical functioning, depression, anxiety, managing emotions and eating disorder symptoms, the two groups did not differ in a statistically clear way.

Something smaller did show up. Emotional distress fell straight after the dog sessions, and the drop was consistent from one session to the next. In their own words, the teenagers described better involvement in therapy, a brighter mood and easier communication.

That matters because a lift in the moment is easy to notice and easy to like, whereas change in a condition takes longer to show. Only the abstract was available to us. The work is a preprint, so it has not been peer reviewed, and eight sessions say little about the long term.

Comparing it with a stress trial

A 2020 German trial of group hypnosis shows how a clearer result looks. It gave 95 people five weekly group sessions and compared them with an information booklet. Perceived stress was lower in the hypnosis group at 5 weeks and at 12 weeks. That trial was open-label, with no attention-matched control, and two of its authors train hypnotherapists, so it too has limits.

The two studies differ in what they measured. The dog trial found a pleasant lift in the moment but no change in the conditions being treated, whereas the hypnosis trial followed a self-reported stress score for twelve weeks. A meta-analysis of hypnosis for anxiety points the same way as the second: across 15 studies, the effect was 0.79 at the end of treatment and 0.99 at follow-up.

What it means for you

  • Ask what was measured: how someone feels in the moment, or how they are weeks later.
  • Look for a comparison group. Feeling better after something is not proof it caused the change.
  • Enjoyable and effective are different questions. Both can matter, and having one tells you little about the other.

Where hypnotherapy fits

Claims about hypnotherapy deserve the same questions, which is why I name the trials behind them. Hypnotherapy can help you relax and relieve anxiety, and sessions teach a practice you can repeat. You can read how hypnotherapy sessions work or see what hypnotherapy helps with.

I'm Tim Dunton, and I have practised hypnotherapy for over two decades. I am a GHR member with NLP training from Bandler and Grinder.

Book a free consultation. Fifteen to thirty minutes, in person in Bournemouth or online, with no obligation: get in touch or call 07975 653893.

The research

1. Dog-assisted therapy in a mental health day hospital, randomised mixed-methods preprint, Europe PMC, November 2026. https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-10229857/v1

2. Fisch S et al, group hypnosis for stress reduction, randomised trial, BMC Complement Med Ther, 2020. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7664040/

3. Valentine KE et al, hypnosis for anxiety, meta-analysis, Int J Clin Exp Hypn, 2019. https://doi.org/10.1080/00207144.2019.1613863

Tags: research · anxiety · stress · wellbeing

Read more: what I help with. Or browse all Everyday Wellbeing posts.

Book a free consultation

15–30 minutes by phone or video, no obligation.

Ask a question or book a free consultation

An email address or a phone number is enough.

How should we contact you?

We use your details only to reply to you. See our privacy policy.

FollowClose